Skip to content

Short-Term Disability Insurance

Short-Term Disability Insurance

Committed to Fighting for You

Investing in a short-term disability insurance policy can give you the peace of mind of knowing you will be financially protected if you are temporarily unable to work due to an injury or illness. In these situations, your policy will cover a portion of your paycheck, giving you the time and resources that you need to focus on getting better. Unfortunately, some insurance carriers will unfairly reject legitimate claims.

Social Security Disability

Back pay awarded for Social Security Disability case.

If your short-term disability insurance claim has been wrongfully denied, our team at Pinyerd Disability Law, LLC is ready to helpOur Indianapolis short-term disability insurance lawyers have over a decade of experience and have won millions for our clients. We have seen it all and know how to effectively approach these cases. You will work directly with our attorneys, who will walk you through all available legal options and provide the compassionate representation you deserve.

Get in touch with our team to learn more about how we can help you get the benefits you need. Contact us online or call (317) 348-1800 to discuss your legal options.

How Short-Term Disability Insurance Works

Many working professionals choose to protect their incomes and livelihoods through short-term disability insurance, especially if their chosen occupation comes with a certain level of risk. Some employers also offer short-term disability insurance as an employment benefit. Policyholders or their employers will pay a monthly premium to maintain coverage.

Short-term disability insurance is designed to cover temporary injuries and illnesses that policyholders will generally recover from. Examples of conditions that might be covered under a plan include an incapacitating illness, a broken limb, a debilitating surgery, or childbirth complications.

These policies can cover up to 60% of a policyholder’s paycheck during a benefit period. Some plans impose maximum caps.

When a policyholder sustains a qualifying injury or illness that prevents them from working, they will submit a claim that includes evidence of the condition. In most cases, you will need to also provide a professional medical opinion that verifies that you are temporarily unable to work. If your claim is approved, you will need to wait through an “elimination period” before you can start receiving benefits. Many policies’ waiting periods last about two weeks.

Once the elimination period is over, your benefit period will begin. A set portion of your paycheck will be covered until you have recovered, your benefit period ends, or your maximum cap is reached, whichever comes first. The scope and duration of your benefit period will depend on your specific insurance policy. Most plans will cover at least several months. Our Indianapolis short-term disability insurance attorneys can carefully evaluate your policy and help you understand what you are entitled to.

How Short-Term Disability Insurance Differs from Other Types of Disability Insurance

Short-term disability insurance policies are meant to cover situations where an injured or ill person can return to work within a few months. Both long-term disability insurance and Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) cover cases where someone will be unable to work for a significantly longer period of time.

Long-term disability insurance functions similarly to short-term disability insurance. Policyholders pay a monthly premium in exchange for a portion of their paycheck being covered if they cannot work. However, coverage generally only triggers when someone will be unable to work for at least three months. These policies tend to cover up to 80% of a policyholder’s paycheck, and certain plans can allow for benefit periods of years, decades, or even until retirement. However, these policies typically impose longer elimination periods and are considerably more expensive than short-term disability policies.

Short-term disability and long-term disability insurance policies are private arrangements, while Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) is a public government benefit program. Workers who work jobs covered by Social Security accrue work credits. If someone sustains a qualifying disability and will consequently be unable to work for a year or more, they may qualify for monetary benefits if they have sufficient work credits.

Fighting a Denied Short-Term Disability Claim

Some insurance companies habitually deny claims on arbitrary or insufficient grounds. When a claim is rejected, the policyholder will not receive the benefits they are depending on in their time of need.

Insurance companies will resort to many excuses to justify a denied claim, including:

Insufficient medical evidence.

When submitting a claim, a policyholder must convince their insurance company that their injury or illness prevents them from working. This will generally involve providing a professional medical diagnosis that confirms the policyholder should not work until they recover. Insurance carriers will sometimes send medical evidence to their own doctors and obtain a dissenting opinion. The contradictory opinion can be used to reject a claim.

Injury or illness not covered by the policy.

Some plans will only cover certain types of conditions, and certain ailments may be explicitly excluded. Some insurers will even use deliberately ambiguous policy language to justify denial of benefits, even if an injury or illness appears to be covered.


It is important to be accurate and precise when submitting a claim to your insurance carrier, as they will heavily scrutinize any perceived inconsistency. If an insurance company believes it has been misled, it may attempt to deny benefits.

Our Indianapolis short-term disability insurance lawyers are ready to advocate for you if your claim has been wrongfully denied. At Pinyerd Disability Law, LLC, we will explore all available legal options, including appeals and litigation.

Do not let your insurance company push you around. Call (317) 348-1800 or contact us online today!

Do not let your insurance company push you around. Call (317) 348-1800 or contact us online today!

Get Pinyerd law on Your Side

Reach Out Today to Speak With Our Experienced Attorneys
Trustworthy and Experienced

We have years of experience handling all disability cases, earning the respect of our community.

It’s Personal to Us

We handle each case with the care you deserve, and we’ll treat you like family.

You’ll Speak to an Attorney

Your case will be personally handled by a licensed attorney, not a legal assistant.

We’ll Take Care of Everything

As our client, you can trust us to be with you every step of the way.

A Higher Winning Percentage

We know what it takes to win your case, and our track record proves it.

Pinyerd Disability Law, LLC

Indianapolis Location

9201 N. Meridian Street, Suite 210, Indianapolis, IN 46260

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

Privacy Policy